If you've ever tried hiring a video editor on Upwork and ended up with a missed deadline, terrible communication, or a 30-second video that somehow took three weeks, you're not alone.

‍

Upwork isn't the problem.

‍
The hiring process is.

‍

Everyone loves to say “just outsource it,” but no one talks about the systems, filters, and real-world steps it actually takes to hire someone who’s not a disaster.

‍

This blog is that conversation. It's everything I've learned from hiring editors that don't suck. And if you want the exact templates, test project framework, and interview questions, I put the full thing in a guide you can download right here.

‍

And let me be upfront about something. If you're just looking to get one or two videos edited here and there, one editor might be enough. But if you're building a brand, running a firm, or managing a marketing calendar that needs consistent video content, you don’t just need an editor. You need a team. A plug and play system that shows up, is available 9am to 5pm EST Monday through Friday, turns raw footage into polished content without your constant input, and never flakes.

‍

That’s what I break down in the guide. How to figure out what you really need, and then how to hire for it.

‍

Let’s get into it.

‍

Step 1: Your Job Post Is Attracting the Wrong Editors

‍

Most Upwork job posts read like this:

‍

“Looking for a video editor for social media content. Need 2 to 3 videos per week. Quick turnaround. Must be creative. Budget: $150.”

‍

That post will get you 57 applications.

‍
56 of them will be trash.

‍

Why?

‍
Because it’s vague. Because it doesn’t qualify. Because it’s asking for help, not attracting talent.

‍

Here’s what actually works:

‍

• Be specific about the outcome, not just the task
  
  
• Show examples of your brand tone or content style
  
  
• Include a soft test in the job post itself
  
  

If you're not screening in the job description, you're playing editor roulette. Want the job post I use? It's in the guide.

‍

Step 2: Use a One-Two Screening Combo

‍

Once the applications start rolling in, most people open 20 tabs, skim portfolios, and just pick whoever’s “pretty good.”

‍

That’s how you get burned.

‍

Here’s what I do instead:

‍

1. Instant Filter Question

‍

I include one question in the application that screens for:

‍

• Communication skills
  
  
• Attention to detail
  
  
• Alignment with my creative style
  
  

This question eliminates 80 percent of applicants.

‍

2. Mini Paid Test Project

‍

Before I ever hop on a call, I pay the top 2 to 3 candidates to complete a small, structured edit using our actual footage.

‍
Same file, same direction, same deadline.

‍

You’ll learn more in one test edit than a 30-minute interview ever will.

‍

I break this exact process down, including the creative brief I use, in the downloadable guide.

‍

Step 3: Hire for the Role, Not the Vibe

‍

This is where most people mess up.

‍

They confuse “cool personality” with “can deliver consistently.”

‍

You’re not hiring a video editor because you need a creative buddy.

‍
You’re hiring one because you need a content machine that doesn't break when things get busy.

‍

So here’s what I always make clear during onboarding:

‍

• Turnaround time expectations
  
  
• Feedback and revisions process
  
  
• How we manage assets, filenames, and brand guidelines
  
  
• Who they report to and what success looks like
  
  

If this sounds like overkill for a freelancer, remember this. You’re not hiring freelancers. You’re building systems.

‍

Bonus Tip: Your Budget Is Only Part of the Equation

‍

Yes, you can hire good editors on Upwork for under $500 a month.

‍
But if you want great work fast and reliable, you either need to pay more or build a system that makes average editors perform at a high level.

‍

And most people don’t know how to do that.

‍

That’s why I wrote this guide.

‍

Download the Full Hiring System

‍

I put together the exact process I use to hire editors that don’t suck, on Upwork and beyond.

‍

It includes:

‍

• My copy-paste job post
  
  
• The exact filter question I use
  
  
• My paid test project template
  
  
• Onboarding checklist
  
  
• Communication workflows
  
  

This is the stuff no one else shows you. Not theory. Not fluff. Just what works.

‍

➡️ Download the guide here and fix your editor problem for good.